What is a newie?
A newie is a song whose lyric is built entirely from words belonging to a discrete category. The writer arranges and phrases those words so the same sung line can be heard two different ways, as a list of words from the song’s category or as a conventional lyric with a story or meaning of its own.
Generally, the two readings should relate to each other. The conventional lyric might reflect on the subject of the word bank, play off it, or cast it in a different light.
The word bank Trees gives the songwriter only names of trees to work with. In Fig. 2, victory is described as the result of rough hewing. We can see how the tree names supply both the sounds of the lyric and the material of its central image.
To find a connection like that, the songwriter starts by looking at what holds the word bank together, how its words relate to one another, and what those relationships might suggest.
Over the course of a newie, the subject of the word bank shapes the lyric’s images and helps determine where it goes. The lyric, in turn, brings out something unexpected about the category that yielded it. The aim is a song whose meaning is inseparable from the material of its construction.
One can imagine the Rapa Nui long ago, chanting at the seashore, “The world is made of lists.”
…and who writes them?
The Newies began in the mid-1990s, when two friends entertained the modest proposition that their new songwriting method would sweep the world, rendering everything that came before … the oldies. Thirty years later, newies are older than some of the stuff now called oldies.
It’s unclear what that proves.
Yet for the writer behind Newies But Gooeys, the method has remained central to his artistic pursuit throughout the decades. Always testing the limits of the counterintuitive, though now rarely disputed, idea that constraint favors inspiration, The Newies go balls to the wall and come out on the other side.
Saw why the home is shakin’.
Oh why? Oh why? Oh, what, you’re chicken?
Here, rhyme gives the writer a second constraint alongside the word bank.
For him, this connection has always carried a heavy spiritual weight, manifesting in a certain suspicion—that when good art emerges under constraint, an unseen hand gets to work in the space the artist has left vacant. And each limitation advertises its own particular treasure. As a teenager he experimented with poetic forms, pulled mismatched topics out of ornate punch bowls, forswore verbs entirely … always chasing the next artistic handicap, grasping for that unseen hand.
But one issue kept coming back to him. Every one of his self-imposed limitations was too … well … self-imposed. He found himself late at night, looking out his bedroom window, asking, If the imposed-upon is also the imposer, is there really any imposition at all?
The groundbreaking discovery of natural word bank songwriting came in a bagel shop on Long Island in December 1996. He was staring through the glass at the options.
“Either Everything or Plain,” he joked.
“That’s some range,” said his friend.
They never wrote the bagel newie. It’s still out there—Sesame, Poppy, Cinnamon Raisin, Rainbow … That one felt laughably impossible, and they moved on to the alphabet.
Try writing a bagel newie in Lyricsetter ↗
But they had a hunch. By writing lyrics using only words from the most fundamental categories of existence, whether linguistic, geographic, anatomical, or culinary, the artist might at last relinquish that last bit of control and acknowledge the rightful Leader of the Band.
Haters will claim that natural word bank writing is no less self-imposed than a no-verb rule. After all, no one is forcing The Newies to write songs this way.
Fair point. And one might add that only those limitations imposed by the Creator can truly be pinned on an Outsider. We talk here about the limitations of one’s own natural abilities, of which The Newies admit many. But by definition, this is exactly where their limitations have led them.
So, there you go.
And to answer the question—who writes newies? At the moment, it may be just the songwriter behind The Newies and their debut album Newies But Gooeys. But as you can see, things are finally picking up!